Once Upon a Time in America Is Every Bit as Great a Gangster Movie as The Godfather


When Once Upon a Time in America first ran in theaters, there were reports that people in the audience laughed when Deborah is reintroduced after a 35-year gap in the action. She hadn’t aged at all. But Deborah is representational to Leone, beyond the character.

“Age can wither me, Noodles,” she says. But neither the character nor the director will allow the audience to see it beyond the cold cream. Deborah is the character Leone is answering to. She also embodies the fluid chronology of the storytelling. She is its only constant.

The rest of the film can feel like a free fall though. Whereas The Godfather moved in a linear fashion, Once Upon a Time in America has time for flashbacks, and flashbacks within flashbacks, and detours that careen between the violent and the quiet. It’s a visceral experience about landing where we, and this genre, began.

Growing up Gangster

Both The Godfather and Once Upon a Time in America span decades; it’s the history of immigrant crime in 20th century America. But they differ on chronological placement. Once Upon a Time is set in three time-frames. The earliest is 1918 in the Jewish ghettos of New York City’s Lower East Side. 

Young Noodles (Scott Tiler), Patrick “Patsy” Goldberg (Brian Bloom), Philip “Cockeye” Stein (Adrian Curran) and Dominic (Noah Moazezi), are a bush league street gang doing petty crimes for a minor neighborhood mug, Bugsy (James Russo). New on the block, Max (Rusty Jacobs) interrupts the gang as they’re about to roll a drunk, and Max makes off with the guy’s watch for himself. He soon joins the gang, and they progress to bigger crimes.

The bulk of the film takes place, however, from when De Niro’s Noodles gets out of prison in 1930, following Bugsy’s murder, and lasts until the end of Prohibition in 1933. Max, now played by Woods, has become a successful bootlegger with a mortuary business on the side. With William Forsythe playing the grown-up Cockeye and James Hayden as Patsy, the mobsters go from bootlegging through contract killing, and ultimately to backing the biggest trucking union in the country as enforcers. They enjoy most of their downtime in their childhood friend Fat Moe’s (Larry Rapp) speakeasy. Noodles is in love with Fat Moe’s sister, Deborah, who is on her way to becoming a Hollywood star. The gang’s rise ends with the liquor delivery massacre.

You May Like Also

  • Share on Facebook (opens in a new tab)
  • Share on Twitter (opens in a new tab)
  • Share on Linkedin (opens in a new tab)
  • Taxi Driver: A Look at NYC’s Inglorious Past
  • The King of Comedy: What’s the Real Punchline of the Martin Scorsese Classic?
  • The Godfather Coda: The Death of Michael Corleone Proves a Little Less is Infinitely More
  • Mob Antipasta: Best Gangster Movie Food Scenes
  • Ferris Bueller’s Day Off
  • Belfast: Kenneth Branagh Remembers a Childhood That's a Million Miles from Shakespeare
  • Home Sweet Home Alone Reboot Will Ruin Your Christmas
  • Red Notice Review: Dwayne Johnson Leads Formulaic Fun
  • Share on Facebook (opens in a new tab)
  • Share on Twitter (opens in a new tab)
  • Share on Linkedin (opens in a new tab)
  • Why The Godfather Part IV Never Happened
  • Redeeming The Legacy Of The Godfather Part III
  • The Real Goodfellas: Gangsters That Inspired the Martin Scorsese Film
  • Why Harvey Keitel's Lansky Looks for Goodness in Bad Men
  • PC Gaming’s Unsung Heroes: Best Components for Your Build Beyond a GPU and CPU
  • Doctor Who: Perfect 10? How Fandom Forgets the Dark Side of David Tennant's Doctor
  • Stephen King’s Favorite TV Shows According to His Twitter Raves
  • The Most Impactful Cards of Magic: The Gathering Adventures in the Forgotten Realms